MEDIA – OUR LAST DEFENCE

Media is all that stands between Jamaica and the abyss.

In Jamaica, governance remains based on the archaic, autocratic, Westminster Model; big business owns government; and citizens are denied the right to vote or any voice in the administration of “elected” governments. Citizens’ only remedy is a free, independent media exposing what others wish hidden. Before the intellectual illiterati start on me about “obligation” to vote and how bad I am for not voting, I repeat, we’ve NO RIGHT TO VOTE.

Firstly, we’ve zero input into “elections” for either party’s leader. Obscure, unelected “delegates” decide who’ll be thrust upon the majority of Jamaicans as candidate for Prime Minister. WE HAVE NO RIGHT TO VOTE IN THAT “ELECTION”. Not even parties’ general membership has a vote. Then, equally obscure executive committees or “selection run-offs” with only “delegates” polled decide who’ll seek our “vote” for constituency representative. WE HAVE NO RIGHT TO VOTE IN THAT “SELECTION”

Finally, we’re unleashed at “general elections” once every five years and told to “vote” for a constituency candidate. Gee, thanks. But, our vote for that candidate is really a vote for his/her party leader as Prime Minister. Suppose you’d accept candidate X as MP but couldn’t support his/her leader for cook’s assistant never mind Prime Minister? If you vote for the MP of your choice you’ve been forced to vote for a prospective Prime Minister you don’t support. Is that democracy? Is that a right to vote?

Now, suppose you could support one of the Prime Ministerial candidates thrust upon you without electoral consultation? In order to vote for that Prime Minister, you MUST vote for the constituency candidate forced upon you (without electoral consultation) by that party. Suppose you’d rather have an alzheimered albatross as M.P? Do you REALLY have a vote? Is that democracy? Or hypocrisy?

In such an anti-democratic system, to whom can we turn?

Only free, independent, ethical media can help us. For weeks, I’ve been writing on media ethics but the intellectual illiterati, unable to see the danger of opaque media reporting on opaque government, called my efforts “personal attacks”; “cass-cass” or whatever. I’ve given varied examples of how opaque media threatens media’s fragile credibility but, rather than deal with substantive issues, many prefer shooting the messenger. God bless ’em. But the camel’s back breaks when constructive criticism of a government-owned company is censored or banned from media on the government-owned company’s instruction.

I wrote on Tuesday (What Price Information) about the tribulations of Donovan “Minister of Information” Wilson, a seasoned, respected horseracing journalist, whose paid inserts in official racebook Track and Pools critical of government-owned Caymanas Track Limited (CTL) were repeatedly banned from publication without stated reason. On Tuesday, for the first time, a reason, in the form of the following Editor’s note, was offered:

Track & Pools is a horse-racing magazine published by Popular Printers Ltd, a subsidiary of The Gleaner Company. The magazine is the official programme for racing at CTL and in its production, there is collaboration between Popular Printers and CTL.

After Track & Pools discontinued the publication of ALL letters, regardless of content, attempts were made to circumvent that decision by the insertion of letters as paid advertisements. That, too, was discontinued, as all Track & Pools ads must promote bona fide products or services.”

Oh, dear. How does one “circumvent” an alleged decision that hasn’t been published anywhere? How come his first two articles slipped under the radar until their popularity adversely affected CTL who then imposed the ban? Why didn’t Track and Pools’ publication director, who first told Wilson he was banned, simply state this reason at that time? After Wilson’s first article (now called an attempt “to circumvent that decision”) Track and Pools published, free of charge, a full-page letter to the editor by Vin Lumsden rebuking Wilson for his critique. When Wilson tried to reply, his was spiked.

How’d Vin successfully “circumvent” the new rule but Donovan’s reply couldn’t? Why’s the Gleaner defending government muzzling criticism of a government-owned company? Does CTL, a government-owned company, dictate publication policy to the Gleaner and its subsidiaries? Every issue contains the following: “Track and Pools is published under the sanction of the Jamaica Racing Commission and CTL”. Does the Racing Commission “sanction” government banning criticism of government? Does Prime Minister Portia support this crass censorship?

When Pat Rousseau was CTL Chairman, letters from many antagonists including current Deputy Chairman, Andrew Azar, savagely critical of CTL, regularly appeared in Track and Pools. That was nothing new. What’d be new is a “decision” not to publish letters. Apparently, Deputy Chairman Azar didn’t get the memo because, on April 25, he wrote to the Gleaner’s Editor-in-Chief extracted (for word count issues only) as follows:

“Dear Editor

….I write you today re an issue that has come up regarding the publishing of letters in the Track and Pools Race-Book. I understand from Mr. Donovan Wilson (a writer to the book) that after two letters that he wrote that happened to be critical of the operations at CTL his letters have been ‘banned’ or not allowed to be published in that publication. Is this indeed true? And if so how could it be? And if it is true is it only his letters that are not allowed to be published, or will the ban include my letters, or any other citizen who wish for their voice to be heard? Is it only letters critical of CTL that will not be allowed, or is it all letters even complimentary ones that will not be published? One of the gentleman’s letters was entitled ‘Does CTL have a Marketing Team?’ and went on to criticize the role of CTL’s marketing team and the job they are doing. I’m the board member in charge of marketing racing so in essence his criticism was also of me, as the buck stops with me.

I thought some of his criticism was wrongly directed but I also thought it was his right to express his opinion even though critical of me. I thought that we still had freedom of speech in this country. Jamaica is going downhill fast enough Mr. Grandison without us also taking away the right of a citizen to criticize. Before I was appointed to the CTL board, I myself was the author of many harsh and hard letters criticizing the management and running of CTL. My letters were much harder and harsher and more probing than those penned by Mr. Wilson, yet my letters were never ‘censored’ or restricted by the publisher. What has changed today? We may not always like to hear what people say about us no matter how critical they are, but in my opinion we must always fight to protect the right of persons to air their views. If not we have started down a very slippery slope……”

Best Regards,

Andrew Azar

Deputy Chairman CTL”

No reply. Andrew has been unable to secure a meeting with either Gleaner or Track and Pools whose publication director has specifically refused to meet him. What’s going on?

Talk about the thin edge of the wedge. Media is Jamaica’s last hope for transparency. True transparency cures most ills because it enables us to recognize when we’re being bamboozled, tricked, swindled, deceived, hoodwinked or scammed. Recognition is trickery’s worst enemy. Government won’t be transparent anytime soon so media must be.

We’ve a right to know who’s paying the piper. We’ve a right to insist our oldest and most respected newspaper doesn’t take instructions from government-owned companies to suddenly muzzle critique on the facile basis “Track & Pools ads must promote bona fide products or services”. Why? If that’s the standard, why isn’t Wilson’s opinion a “bona fide” service? Sheesh!

Of what is the Gleaner afraid? That CTL might revoke its licence to print Track and Pools? So what? Just as alleged human rights activists must fight to the death for human rights, I expect all media to fight to the death for press freedom. Tell CTL to take its licence and shove it!

Peace and Love

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: